Pair jailed for 20 years for unprovoked murder in Paisley

Author: Rob WallerPublished 13th Feb 2020

Life sentences are being handed down to two men who killed a Paisley father in an unprovoked attack after ambushing him at his flat.

Stephen O'Donnell, 30, and Robert Muir, 30, punched, kicked and stamped on 48 year old George Calvert's head in Glen Street on March 19th last year.

They'll both have to serve at least 20 years before there's any chance of parole.

Mr Calvert died from a massive brain injury hours after the brutal attack. He had 63 injuries – 26 of them to his head and neck.

Part of the attack took place inside Mr Calvert's home and his brutal killers left him dying on the landing outside his home.

At the High Court in Glasgow judge Lady Rae told the pair: “You were both found guilty by a jury of what can only be described as a brutal and savage attack on a man in his own home.

“He suffered multiple injuries to his head and body caused by you two kicking, punching and stamping on him.

“I detect little or no remorse. You O'Donnell tried to minimise your involvement and Muir you said you have no memory of events.”

At the time of the murder both men were on community payback orders – O'Donnell for drink driving and driving while disqualified and Muir for an assault with a bottle.

Prosecutor Graeme Jessop said: “They both had appointments for the community payback orders that morning – but were sent away.”

The court heard that both men then headed to O'Donnell's flat where they sat drinking and in the afternoon murdered Mr Calvert.

O'Donnell , who was in a relationship with 19-year-old Kisteen Templeton, feared that Mr Calvert would tell her jealous ex-boyfriend Robert Cowan about them.

Before heading to Mr Calvert's flat O'Donnell told his friend Muir “George saw me and her walking about and I wouldn't be surprised if he tells Robert Cowan.'”

And Muir replied: “'He'll no be saying f all to any c,'” and added: “Don't worry. I'll back you 110 per cent”

The sound of the horrific beating and Mr Calvert whimpering was heard by people in neighbouring flats.

The callous pair left Mr Calvert dying.

Minutes afterwards O'Donnell told Ms Templeton: “We've just done George in.”

O'Donnell , who lived in the same block of flats, tried to fool police by telling them he just had arrived home and found the street 'like a CSI parking lot.”

His accomplice Muir asked Ms Templeton to lie for them and say they were in O'Donnell's flat all day.

They were brought to justice because their clothes and shoes were covered in droplets of Mr Calvert's blood.

Muir's handprint in Mr Calvert's blood was found on a wall close to where Mr Calvert lay.

Prosecutor Graeme Jessop said: “This was a concerted attack, a vicious attack and a sustained attack on a man who was ambushed at his front door as he came back home. It was unprovoked.”

They had both earlier offered pleas of guilty to the lesser charge of culpable homicide, but these were rejected.

Tony Graham QC, representing O'Donnell said: “It was never the intention to do more than an assault or a breach of the peace, but it escalated.”

Defence counsel Thomas Ross QC for Muir said: “He doesn't remember anything about the offence due to intoxication.”