Strict liability won't work in Scottish football, says Neil Doncaster

The SPFL chief executive is calling for more severe punishments for individuals

Published 5th Apr 2022

SPFL chief executive Neil Doncaster says strict liability isn't the way forward for Scottish football.

It comes after a string of incidents involving supporters during Rangers' 2-1 defeat to Celtic on Sunday.

The start of the second-half was delayed after a glass bottle was thrown from the home end into the Celtic penalty box.

A member of Ange Postecoglou's backroom staff also required stitches after being struck by a missile launched from the stand.

However, Doncaster is explaining why strict liability for clubs wouldn't work in Scottish football.

Instead, he is calling for more severe punishments for the individuals involved.

Speaking to the Time, Doncaster said: “Strict liability simply does not work, as the repeated fines for specific clubs in Uefa competitions season after season demonstrate very clearly.

“The answer must be far harsher and targeted punishments for the individuals who perpetrate the crime, including a more regular use of football banning orders and, where necessary, custodial sentences.

“There are two main forms of strict liability which have been proposed and neither of them will work.

"The first is to punish the home club for any transgressions in their ground, whether it’s by the away fans or home fans. Unfortunately, this will act as an incentive for some away fans to misbehave, knowing the home clubs will suffer the punishment for their actions. It will inevitably result in clubs refusing to sell tickets to away fans, with the obvious detrimental impact on our game.

“The second is to make clubs strictly liable for the behaviour of their fans at away matches and this will simply lead to clubs refusing to sell their fans tickets for other grounds, for fear of being punished if they misbehave.

“The significant investment by clubs in CCTV technology means it’s far easier to spot and act on incidents caused by the tiny minority of fans who misbehave. Clubs, footballing authorities and the overwhelming majority of decent fans abhor the actions of those who engage in criminal acts at games.

"It’s only by targeting these individuals directly and punishing them to the full extent of the law that we will provide a meaningful and effective deterrent.”