Isle of Wight prisoners win damages over serious fire

A judge says the Ministry of Justice admitted a 'breach of duty'

Author: Brian Farmer, PAPublished 23rd Jun 2022

Prisoners who said they suffered physical and psychiatric harm after a serious fire broke out at a jail seven years ago have settled damages claims after taking legal action against the Ministry of Justice, a High Court judge has been told.

More than 20 people - who were prisoners when fire broke out at Isle of Wight Prison, near Newport, in February 2015 - have been involved in the litigation.

Mr Justice Soole, who is based in London, had been due to make decisions about damages at a trial.

But barristers told the judge, at an online High Court hearing on Wednesday, that settlements had been reached.

No detail was aired at the hearing, but lawyers had given the judge information in written submissions.

Lawyers representing prisoners had said, in a written case outline, that the fire had been "started intentionally" by a prisoner who was a "known arsonist", when all other prisoners were locked in cells and unable to "evacuate themselves".

"The impact of the fire on the other prisoners, prison officers and the prison buildings was significant," said the case outline.

"Thankfully, no-one was killed.

"However, some of the prisoners in the affected part of the prison suffered injury from smoke inhalation and ongoing psychiatric harm as a result of their traumatic experience."

Lawyers said the "arsonist" had been prosecuted.

More than 20 people who were prisoners alleged "a series of breaches of duty" by the Ministry of Justice.

Mr Justice Soole had been told how the Ministry of Justice had initially denied allegations but had subsequently admitted a "breach of duty".

The Ministry of Justice describes Isle of Wight Prison, on a website, as a high security men's prison, set across two sites just outside Newport.

A BBC news report had, in 2015, said 10 people needed treatment as a result of the fire.

The report said a hospital had declared a "major incident".

A spokeswoman for law firm Leigh Day, which represented claimants, said, after the hearing, that the firm had no comment.

A Ministry of Justice spokesman said later:

"We only settle when it is in the interest of taxpayers and any outstanding debts owed to victims must be paid before prisoners receive a penny."

Hear all the latest news from across the UK on the hour, every hour, on Greatest Hits Radio on DAB, at greatesthitsradio.co.uk, and on the Greatest Hits Radio app.