SNP promoting "civil conflict" in independence push, says David Davis

The Brexit Secretary mocked accusations that the upcoming general election was solely about capitalising on poor Labour polling and tackling rivalries within the Conservative Party

Published 27th Apr 2017
Last updated 27th Apr 2017

David Davis has accused the SNP of promoting “civil conflict” in their quest for independence as he faced pressure over protecting workers after Brexit.

The Brexit Secretary mocked accusations that the upcoming general election was solely about capitalising on poor Labour polling and tackling rivalries within the Conservative Party, rather than the negotiations to leave the European Union.

SNP Europe spokesman Stephen Gethins raised concerns over potential job losses at Diageo, amid claims that the drinks giant is moving its Scottish vodka production abroad due to fears about Brexit.

Speaking during the final Brexit questions of this Parliament, Mr Gethins said: After these questions we go into a general election which the EU has already said will make very little difference to its negotiations.

"It's got a lot more to do with exploiting a civil war on the Labour benches and preventing yet another civil war on the Tory benches.”

He accused ministers of being “asleep at the wheel” and failing to prevent major job losses from firms nervous about the consequences of Brexit.

To jeers of outrage from the opposition, Mr Davis joked: “I suppose if there's one thing I should take lectures from the SNP on, it's promoting civil conflict.

“In terms of the question he put, is it now a priority the promotion of the economy? The answer is yes?”

Mr Gethins hit back, saying the SNP was out-polling the Tories because of its focus on securing a good deal in Europe.

He added: “The Secretary of State has put aside these negotiations for narrow political benefit that he won't have in Scotland. What is he going to do about these threats to jobs?”

Mr Davis responded: “We will seek the best possible deal to maintain our relationship with the European Union and over and above that we will seek the best possible deal with the rest of the world, where we already get 60% of exports from.”

Brexit minister David Jones later told SNP MP Steven Paterson (Stirling) to look “for the opportunities of Brexit, not be a wet blanket” after he raised trade concerns.

SNP trade spokeswoman Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh asked Mr Jones to explain what assessments his department have made on the impact of Brexit on Scottish trade, adding: “Or is it simply a fingers crossed approach?”

She claimed answers from the Scotland Office to written parliamentary questions suggest it has “not made any” such assessment.

Mr Jones replied: “I'm surprised to hear that. As I said a moment ago, in fact the Scotch Whisky Association itself has identified enormous opportunities from Brexit.

“So I think when you go back to your constituency to do a bit of campaigning, you might go to your nearest distillery and ask them what they think.”

Mr Davis later accused the SNP of wanting to “give 60 billion” to the EU, an apparent reference to suggestions from Brussels that Britain will have to pay a £50 billion - or 60 billion euro - exit charge.

SNP MP Hannah Bardell (Livingston) said: “What kind of deal do you think you're likely to get if you and your Government refuse to pay their dues in Europe?

“Surely negotiations are about give and take.”

Mr Davis replied: “It's interesting the Scottish National Party wants to give 60 billion - I hadn't realised that up until now.”